Great question and topic!
Thanks KEW; glad you participated as well!
To feed off of your question and HighFigh's response, what are your preferred EQ settings in the car when the engine is not running and you are sitting still?
That's a good question -- I never really tried that in those conditions; what I have found is this:
When I first got the car, I used some favorite CDs that I knew were well-mastered to adjust the Bass, Treble and Midrange off from their "0" midway points (the system allows adjustment for each of these from "-5" points to "0" and then to "+5" points for the extreme), allowing me to adjust the settings to what I casually thought my ear was liking. This developed adjustments of slightly higher Treble settings, like a point or two over the Bass, with Midrange in the "+2" adjustment.
I then stumbled upon a Lexus Enthusiast site in which an owner of a new gorgeous LS Sport did a review of the car, and he stated that he set his Mark Levinson system's settings to "Bass: +3,"Midrange: +2" and "Treble: +1" and set this way, his system sounded like "the equivalent of a high-end home component system"...my reasoning for copying these settings into my JBL system was that with my car being the "parent poor man's" version of the Lexus models (so to speak) and my JBL coming from the same factory as his Mark Levinson, his settings could have been ideal for my car, too -- but perhaps I shouldn't have thought this way because it's much like the TV calibration theory...that you shouldn't just "plug in" someone else's picture settings even though they may have the same model.
Then, I started thinking about my home two channel and surround systems, and how I keep the Bass and Treble on those at "flat" and never had a problem -- so I started fooling around with the JBL car system at "0" across the board as well, the thinking being "well, if my home system sounds good flat without needing tone boost, the car system needs to be set this way too..."
But I don't know; in the car, it does sound sweeter with the bass cranked up and the treble up a bit...the midrange is the most difficult thing to set, as no matter how I play with it, I can't make out if it's making the sound better or worse.
Also, I'm not at all convinced that having the tone controls set to "flat" is truly flat. I have to wonder, since the manufacturer has an unprecedented level of knowledge of conditions (the specific speakers, their position, cabin noise characteristics, and listening space) if they don't take license to tweak things as they see fit. Or, another way to look at it is "what vehicle conditions do they tune for?"
Right -- and totally understandable. I have wondered that as well; I mean, what makes JBL/Toyota so right when they say their "0" mark is "flat"? In the system, the "0" mark represents no bass, treble or midrange adjustment -- but how are we to know if this is "the best" setting for an accurate soundstage?
However, to answer your question; Whatever sounds best to you is the best setting - just be mindful of settings for a specific passage may not be ideal for another song/content. In the end, you are finding the settings that are best "on average".
Indeed; this may be the only answer here. I did try to find the best settings for average playback, as I am not one of those people who like to tweak tone controls for each song -- I want to set it and forget it. It's been the most difficult thing to try and adjust this car system's settings, especially the midrange control, as I don't really know what "sounds best". I have actually driven around with controls at "0" and thought "well, it sounds okay..." but then if I adjust the controls back to where that Lexus owner recommended on his ML system, it indeed sounds punchier and "more alive"...
It is disappointing, IMHO, that manufacturers have gotten away from the Loudness contour control. While depending on the efficiency of your speakers and the manufacturers approach to this control, YMMV; Yamaha's variable loudness contour approach seemed to offer a good solution. I am very happy with the SQ of my current system, but find that I rarely listen to music at lower volumes (say, much below 75-80db) any more and wonder if that is due to the lack of bass and treble (as realized by the human ear) at these lower levels.
I am in total agreement with you -- I cannot stand that my Onkyo stereo receiver doesn't have a Loundness circuit, but oddly enough, the more expensive A-9555 integrated amp has one. Further, a button like this is perfect for low level listening, and I can recall an old Kenwood car head unit I had in a 1991 Nissan 240SX had a loudness button...
