Another bd55 vs s550 question...a quickie though.

E

EddieG

Audioholic
If I can get either for the same price, what is your preference? From what I read on Cnet I'm thinking the Panny...seems it does better audio decoding????
 
Davemcc

Davemcc

Audioholic Spartan
My preference? I kept the BD35 and returned the S550. Purely a subjective decision. I didn't see any significant performance issues with either one.
 
Thunder18

Thunder18

Senior Audioholic
Here's a question for you..

Does your receiver decode DTS HD and Dolby true HD via HDMI? If not and you're primary source of input for these codecs will be multi-channel analog outputs, then get the Panasonic. Why you might ask? Well, with Panasonic you can tell the player in the menu one time that you would like legacy Dolby Digital/DTS to be output over spdif in either bitstream or pcm format allowing the receiver to apply any of the room correction it may be able to do or bass management. With the Sony, you have to go into the menu everytime you switch between a blu-ray with one of the newer codecs or an SD dvd with one of the legacy codecs and tell it to output over spdif because it won't do both at the same time.
So basically, with the 550 which I kept for about a week before I went mad, if I swapped in an sd dvd I had to go into the player's menu choose output bitstream over spdif and then play the movie. Want to watch a blu-ray? Go back into the menu and tell it to output over multi-channel analog via PCM. The Panny 55 will do both and will not require any additional menu changes to do so.

Now to be fair, this only matters if you are using the multi-channel analog outputs. If you have an HDMI equipped receiver that can decode the new formats or receive them via PCM this is not an issue.

Also, the new Sony's won't do a frame by frame advance when a blu-ray is paused...small issue for most probably, but some people find it very annoying.
 
Nomo

Nomo

Audioholic Samurai
Now to be fair, this only matters if you are using the multi-channel analog outputs. If you have an HDMI equipped receiver that can decode the new formats or receive them via PCM this is not an issue.
And if your not going to use the Analog outputs; there is little reason to buy the BD55. Beyond the "vibration absorbing feet" it has little over the BD35.
 
Thunder18

Thunder18

Senior Audioholic
And if your not going to use the Analog outputs; there is little reason to buy the BD55. Beyond the "vibration absorbing feet" it has little over the BD35.
Same deal with the 550 vs. the 350 as well. If your receiver can process the lossless formats, you're safe going with the lower model Sony as well.
 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top