About 2 speaker...mirage omd-5 and definitive technology promonitor 1000

K

kalistan

Audiophyte
Mirage OMD-5 and Definitive Technology Promonitor 1000 speakers. I was wondering which is the better speaker. The Promonitors go down to 43 hz while the OMD-5s reach down to 60 hz. Which is better? The Promonitors may go lower, but do they give the quality as the Mirage speakers in their respective ranges. I'm going to get a Sunfire Subwoofer...would this nullify or minimize the Definitive Technology Promonitor 1000s. Does anyone have characteristics worth noting about either speaker? Thanks for any reply...
 
dkane360

dkane360

Audioholic Field Marshall
There are much better options out there then those if you are looking for a stereo bookshelf setup. Out of those two though, I would pick the def techs. Personally, I don't like the omnidirectional sound of the Mirage's for stereo listening. What's your budget?
 
agarwalro

agarwalro

Audioholic Ninja
OMD-5 Reveiw Thread on AH,

Having seen and heard these speakers before, I had to pick up a couple when I saw Vanns advertising $129 per speaker. I hooked these up to a simple Denon 590 receiver to see how they do in stereo. Mirage puts the OMD-5’s +/-3db point at 60Hz which Audyssey MultEQ confirmed, however, I found 90Hz sounded best to my ears. Audyssey was turned off during my listening.

Packaging: Mirage did a good job packaging the speakers. They wrap the grill separately (but in the same box) and the tweeter assembly of the speaker has shaped plastic over it so that you don’t put your finger on the tweeter while lifting the speaker out of the box. Vanns put both speakers into another box with additional foam which was nice and ensured the speakers would arrive without damage.

Build Quality: The build quality of these speakers is excellent. The finish is flawless and everything fits together perfectly. I’m a fan of wood finishes like the burled maple Mirage uses as every speaker will sport a unique look. The binding posts will accommodate bare wire, spades, and banana plugs no problem. One thing I did find on one of the speakers was a little adhesive inside the binding post attached to the little plastic red cap. A little Goo Gone took care of it and in went the banana plug.

Sound Quality: In the beginning, I didn’t really care for Mirage’s Omni sound, but I have to say, it has grown on me with time and I really like it now. The OMD-5 follows the same design as Mirage’s other Omni offerings so you have the tweeter assembly hovering over the angled midrange driver and another flying saucer looking assembly above the tweeter itself. Very early on, I thought this was a gimmick, but this design actually works as advertised.

I started out my listening with some Diana Krall on SACD. The OMD-5’s handle vocals superbly. Diana’s voice was full and the speakers were revealing of details without being overbearing or fatiguing. The ability of these speakers to simply disappear in the room was excellent as they threw an impressive soundstage.

I switched to my Chesky classical CD and found the upper frequencies to be smooth and extended. String instruments in particular were true to the real instrument. I personally love compositions that are heavy in strings so hearing them so well-produced was a real treat.

Imaging wasn’t as accurate as some direct radiating speakers I’ve heard, but instruments and voices found themselves in the correct general area. I’m really starting to buy into Mirage’s approach to sound as having that hyper-accurate imaging isn’t realistic when you compare it to a live performance.

In summary, the OMD-5’s are very well-balanced speakers. My only complaint would be that the lower midrange was a hair reserved and these aren’t really rock speakers. Also, these speakers love power. I would even go so far to say that an external amp would do them justice. They also don’t reach very low with authority so a good subwoofer is a must. At $129 per speaker, the OMD-5 easily stomps on speakers I’ve heard in the same price range including many of the ID brands. Someone in another thread described the OMD-5 as producing sound that is life like and I would agree with that assessment. Anyone looking for a 5.0 system should seriously consider 5 OMD-5 speakers for $645 shipped.
ProMonitor 1000 comments on AVS,
The Pro Cinema 1000 is very available and got an awesome review in the September 2006 edition of The Perfect Vision, a highly respected a/v magazine.

Their summary:

Strengths:
-Clear High, potent bass
-Mid range with true high end sophistication
-Big Dynamics from small enclosures
-Value with a capital "V"

Weaknesses:
-Could use a smoother tweeter
-You'll need great electronics to get this system's full measure

To me, that last point is not really a weakness but a compliment.
The DefTech summary is just rubbish in terms of offering anything of value.

I would recommend that you bring both home and compare them in your listening conditions. Also, make sure to compare with with a conventional bookshelf speaker since both of those you mentioned have the omni-polar sound.
 
K

kalistan

Audiophyte
I just ordered some....

Thanks for your responses everyone. I found these OMD-5 speakers for 119$. So, I just broke down and bought 5 of them. I figure that with a good subwoofer, the satellite speakers will have enough bass on the bottom end. People said that the Mirage speakers were more musical, and the ProMonitor 1000s were more for home theater. Anyways, I don't think I could have bought a better value.
 
agarwalro

agarwalro

Audioholic Ninja
Nice! Have fun setting up your HT and do post your impressions on the sound.
 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top