5

55katest55

Audioholic
My cable box doesnt support 1080P, but does support everything else. It's currently on 1080i, but i was wondering if 720P would be better. Thoughts?
 
cym_city

cym_city

Junior Audioholic
As far as I am aware no cable company even broadcast in 1080p and instead has to compress the heck out of the signal to send it. For fast moving sports, 720 is for sure the way to go because it refreshes every line of resolution so you don't get the weird stutter. I believe that some of the major networks broadcast in 720 to begin with.
 
BoredSysAdmin

BoredSysAdmin

Audioholic Slumlord
Resolution don't matter - it's cable company fault for over-compressing the content using antique video codec - MPEG2 - the same one which is used for DVD, but someone genius decided it's a good codec for HD content as well - result is crappy as you can notice.

The only "cable" company which doesn't suffer from this is Fios as they claim to send you signal exactly as they received it
 
BMXTRIX

BMXTRIX

Audioholic Warlord
Almost all broadcast television is shot at 1080i or 720p. Major sports networks (ESPN) typically shoot and broadcast at 720p.

Now, as you may have gathered from the previous posts, what the cable companies do with those signals after they get it may completely destroy the quality of the signal. Typically, this comes in the form of significant additional compression to the signal. The key here being that just because something says it is 1080i, it may not be the same quality 1080i as was originally created, and the original may not even have been 1080i.

Let's throw a couple more things into this:

Cable boxes suck at scaling and may provide a lousy image at 1080i or 720p - or both - at all times.

Televisions may provide better scaling than they do deinterlacing, so some TVs handle a 1080i image better than they do a 720p image, or vice-versa. It depends on the manufacturer of the TV, and the model/year of the TV you own.

SOLUTION!

The best way to find out if 720p looks better than 1080i on your setup is really, really, really easy...

TRY IT!

While it's good to ask us what you will like better, it's much better to just change the settings of your cable box and try both settings for a few hours/days and see which one you prefer.

In my experience, I usually leave everything on 1080i and it seems to be satisfactory with my HD viewing.
 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top