Oh man, I just pray no "normal" people ever buy this display.
"Normal" folks already stretch 4:3 content, can't tell an SD channel from an HD one, complain about "black bars" and would prefer to watch a vertically stretched or a cropped image - I can't even imagine how bad things are going to get on a 21:9 screen!
Just imagine the stretch on 4:3 content on this baby! Although, it MIGHT even be so crazy-looking that the "normals" notice something isn't right
The "normals" are never going to figure out how to activate the 21:9 cropping for 2.35:1 features anyway. If they ever DO turn it on, they won't know how to turn it back off, so all of their 16:9 content is going to get cropped (not that they'll notice). And I can just imagine how "awesome" those SD channels are going to look.
No sir, this TV should only be allowed to be sold to people who can pass a written and a practical exam. You should have to earn a licence to operate this thing.
Of course, anyone who cares enough to actually know how aspect ratios work isn't going to want 120Hz processing, crappy half-resolution "passive" 3D, the picture artifacts that will come from cropping and scaling to fill that 21:9 screen, or the super glossy screen surface on this thing. Oh, and they might not like the uneven backlighting, the "cloudy" look of the pseudo-local-dimming, or the way the near side looks black but the far side looks grey if you look at a dark scene from just slightly off-angle.
I like the idea of being able to watch 2.35:1 movies on a screen that is actually larger than the 16:9 portion, but there are just too many problems. It doesn't offer good enough picture quality for the people who will actually know how to use it, and it is going to be completely unmanageable by the "normals".
Lastly, 58" is the biggest size?! What's the point? That's the equivalent of a mere 46.6" screen when you're looking at 16:9 content.
So good idea, but poor execution. I didn't even mention how subtitles on a lot of movies are going to get cut off when the image is cropped to 21:9, or how incredibly bad 2.35:1 DVDs are going to look due to all the interpolation and scaling. If you want the "Cinemascope" experience at home, invest in a front projection setup, not this.