What About Ease of Use?
Just to represent another viewpoint, I'm shopping right now for a second system, for our den. And there's a good chance it's going to be (*gasp*) an HTIB, perhaps this Samsung unit.
We already have a system in another room (our media room) that sounds great, with a Denon receiver, Panansonic Blu-ray, DirecTV, nice speakers, and a dedicated sub and amp. It also has (of necessity) a $400 programmable remote to switch everything between Blu-ray, DirecTV, iPod, and our kids' gaming system. Despite some pretty slick custom programming, should any of the components get out of sync with the others--and it happens more often than anyone would like--it really confuses and frustrates people!
So for the den, I wanted something with Blu-ray and an iPod dock that would be one unit that would take DirecTV as an HDMI input, then deliver a single HDMI output (including audio) to our new Panasonic V10. That would *minimize* the number of components that could be "out of sync" (including just plain turned off), and allow single, simple, remote usage. It really pains me how that ONE ISSUE--component input modes and source switching control--can continue to be the single biggest bane to TV users these days. I'm probably not talking about you and me, dear reader, but rather the people who yell, "Hey, it's not working!!!!" and make us come fix it.
Okay, you'd think that a properly paired Blu-ray player and A/V receiver could be just as simple as integrated unit, except for two issues:
1. The receiver frequently refers to the Blu-ray player as something generic like "Input 1" (not a helpful description: "Hey, how do I get the DVD to play?"..."Turn it to Audio 1!"
2. Sometimes one device gets turned off (in the media room, we "wave the expensive remote" as we push the ON or OFF button to turn on/off all of the requisite devices. Which *mostly* works the first time, and sometimes just makes you look like an idiot waving the remote around while 3/4 of the devices do what they are supposed to. It's awkward to tell someone, "Yeah, that was right. Do it again, but a little more wrist English towards the DirecTV box.")
If someone wants to hulk out and give me some pointers before I fire up (gasp!) one of these HTIB units, I'm all ears.*
*With respect to my ears: yes, I can tell the difference in audio quality with respect to good quality components. We probably differ in that I no longer ignore the "Hey, it's not working!" noise as I calculate the actual signal/noise ratio, though. Do you?
--John