My guess would be that you are accustomed to ported subwoofers, and are underwhelmed by a sealed subwoofer. Depending on the size of your room, one sealed sub may not be sufficient to pressurize your listening space.
The question becomes, do your prefer the tight accuracy of sealed subs, or the booming thunder of a ported sub? (that can sometimes be overdriven and create distortion, 'port chuffing') I am a strong advocate of multiple subs, but many people find them difficult to integrate into a living room.
Just don't give up your sealed sub in exchange for a ported one, with out being sure!