From what I understand about your post, the JVC model does not have an enhanced 16x9 mode. That is a big plus for the sharp model. The JVC has a fixed 480 horizontal lines in a 4x3 aspect so when you watch widescreen DVDs you actually lose vertical resolution. Most modern analog sets have a horizontal resolution of 600-800 lines which is more than adequate to display DVD which is at most 720x480 picture elements. Remember having a set which has a higher maximum horizontal resolution than a DVD image does not improve the picture-i.e. you can't add detail that isn't in the DVD to begin with--but having one that has a lower vertical resolution will always degrade the image. And just to clarify things; 800 lines of resolution means the set can resolve 800 vertical lines in a circle with a diameter which is equal to the height of the screen. Sorry if my post was long winded--go with the Sharp.