DVD audio to CD

[notquitehere188]

I have a number of concerts on DVD and i was wondering if there was a way to take the audio off of them and burn it to a CD still in 5.1 Surround sound so i can play it in my car (with it's fancy schmancy sound system)

[jaxvon]

That would be a negatory. CDs are 2-channel only.

[notquitehere188]

i suspected as much
new mystery, why does my car have 5.1 sound capabilitys if it can only play cds and radio

[AFJumper03]

MAY be capable to play SACDs or DVD-Audio DVDs. More likely than not, you have a faceplace that uses a DVD navagation system (correct me if I'm wrong), and it uses that capability to play supposed 5.1 surround.

[notquitehere188]

i dunno, it has dolby something

[Duffinator]

i suspected as much
new mystery, why does my car have 5.1 sound capabilitys if it can only play cds and radioDo you have a Acura TL? The new ones do have 5.1 sound systems in them and play DVD-A discs. :D I'm reading the brochure as I type this.

[notquitehere188]

Its a volvo but i got a upgraded sound system with it

[j_garcia]

Just because sound comes out of all the speakers does not mean it is 5.1. If your player does not state that it plays DD/DTS/DVD-A, then you are not getting true discrete multichannel sound.

I asked that question before. Do stereo automotive head units use some kind of Pro Logic type decoding to create the rear speaker image? I got no definitive answer. One person said yes, but had nothing to substantiate.

[jaxvon]

I checked out Volvo's site, they use Dolby Pro Logic II. So yeah, it's just emulated surround sound that uses 2 channel as the source.

[Duffinator]

Just because sound comes out of all the speakers does not mean it is 5.1. If your player does not state that it plays DD/DTS/DVD-A, then you are not getting true discrete multichannel sound.Acura advertises the TL has a 5.1/DVD-A system. It's a discrete 5.1 sound system. I would imagine this will be the new direction for many higher end auto sound systems.

http://www.acura.com/models/model_comfort_surround_sound.asp?module=tl

"ACURA/ELS® PREMIUM 8-SPEAKER SURROUND SOUND SYSTEM WITH DVD-AUDIO AND DTS CD 6-DISC CHANGER, AM/FM TUNER AND DOLBY® CASSETTE

The DVD-Audio system is a multi-channel audio system that delivers over 500-times higher resolution than CD-Audio. It also features a frequency response of 192kHz and a dynamic range of 24 bits for rich, clear sound. The AM/FM tuner has a powered antenna built into the rear glass, and XM® Satellite Radio operates from a built-in receiver."

500 times higher??? I guess we have been missing out with our HT systems.

[Lincoln]

I'll ask a similar question: Could you extract the 2-ch audio from a DVD-A and burn a CD with that. I have a few SACDs and DVD-As that I would like to play in my car (at a reduced resolution, of course).

[j_garcia]

I'll ask a similar question: Could you extract the 2-ch audio from a DVD-A and burn a CD with that. I have a few SACDs and DVD-As that I would like to play in my car (at a reduced resolution, of course).

There's no way I know for SACD, however if the discs are hybrids, you can burn the CD layer. I do this all the time, because I don't want to carry around my expensive SACDs. You are not getting the resolution of the SACD layer though.

Not sure about DVD-A, though once it's analog, you should be able to record it with the right gear (same with SACD) Though again, you are not going to pick up the resolution; you are limited to whatever you're recording device is capable of.

[notquitehere188]

it does have a DD logo, if that means anything, also
i got the CD, "Dave Matthews Band, The Central Park Concert" which said it was surround sound, is a a SACD, i cant tell